Verified Document

Pay For Performance Plans In Education Essay

Related Topics:

Pay for Performance Plan Designing a pay for performance plan for teachers is inherently challenging. The outputs for teachers are students, and their educational attainment. It is difficult to quantify educational attainment at the best of times, and because each student is different it can be difficult to specifically identify the role that an individual teacher has on aggregate student performance. The three elements of an effective pay-for-performance plan are efficiency, equity and compliance. Efficiency and equity are both challenging for teachers because of the inherent difficulty in measuring their outputs. There are no efficient and equitable measures. Standardized test scores can be efficient, but they are problematic because they do not directly measure the quality of the teaching, or the students' ability to grasp and apply concepts. Student bodies can vary significantly from school to school, so there is also no equitable way to evaluate teacher performance across an entire state. Compliance is the one piece that might be possible, because the standardized tests are mandatory, but the Georgia example shows that it is necessary to police the testing process carefully.

One of the issues I see with the Georgia pay-for-performance plan...

A better design would be more complex up front, but maintain relative simplicity after that. If teachers were broken down into buckets – by type of class, and by geographically similar areas – there would be greater equity. Geographic regions would be determined on the basis of demographic characteristics – so a poor rural area is not compared with a rich suburban one, for example. Standardized tests could improve , or be augmented with ones that have a subjective element that is graded off-site (like AP tests are), that would allow for more effective measuring of student outcomes. It's more complex, but allows for much greater accurately and equity – and after it's been set up this is only a small sacrifice in efficiency. The final component of a good pay-for-performance plan is compliance. With third party grading, there is a higher degree of compliance as well.
All told, the Georgia case seems to highlight a plan that is oriented towards utmost efficiency, but makes trade-offs in equity and compliance to make that work. By striking a better balance of all three elements of an effective pay-for-performance system, outcomes like the case would be less frequent, and teachers…

Sources used in this document:

References

Chapter 9: Designing a pay-for-performance plan. In possession of the author.


Cite this Document:
Copy Bibliography Citation

Related Documents

Education and Pay for Performance
Words: 886 Length: 2 Document Type: Term Paper

Pay for Performance Systems How could an organization measure the effectiveness of their pay-for-performance plans? In principle, organizations could measure the effectiveness of their pay-for-performance plans by establishing objective criteria for defining "effectiveness" and then measuring those criteria before and after implementation of the plan and comparing those results (Kline & Sulsky, 2009). For example, in a general business organization, the criteria used to evaluate the effectiveness of performance plans might be

Performance Management Is the Process
Words: 2782 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

The other major advantage of the use of a pilot group for conducting evaluations and 360 degree feedback survey is it enables pilot participants to act as champions who promote the process in the rest of the organization. Using Rater Groups: When conducting evaluations and 360 degree feedback assessments, using small but relevant rater groups is one of the best methods. The consideration of the number of people to participate in

Pay for Performance in K-12
Words: 3394 Length: 12 Document Type: Term Paper

, 2001). Prior to 1930, thought, little attention was given to pay-for-performance in the public sector in the United States except for the blue-collar, manufacturing functions that were being primarily performed for the military. During this period in American history, government was viewed (and perhaps still is by many) as a competitive threat to private enterprise; as a result, there was not much public support for developing a highly motivated and

Pay Model Government and Legal
Words: 4353 Length: 10 Document Type: Research Paper

Now, the last one involves the balancing competitiveness with internal alignment through the use of ranges, flat rates, and/or bands. This is very important because a company would want to know who they are competing against and what they have to offer that will be able to go against them in the marketplace. Other things mentioned in this chapter, involve chapter talks about market pay survey (Salvador & Garcia-Menendez,

Pay for Performance
Words: 971 Length: 3 Document Type: Research Paper

Pay for performance is becoming commonplace in the business world. Pay raises and bonuses are often based on how well one performs on the job or on achieving specific results. However, this is not the case in education. Pay levels are typically based on years of experience and levels of education rather than on teacher effectiveness. As concerns about the quality of the nation's educational systems frequently appear in the

Pay for Performance, or Alternately
Words: 2275 Length: 7 Document Type: Term Paper

Plus most teachers saw the pay for performance system as inevitable, and therefore wanted to be involved from the start of the plan (Gratz, 2005). The pilot faced many challenges. Not the least, the district was faced with the logistical challenge of linking the students in various databases to the teachers. The internal systems for tracking student progress by teacher simply didn't exist. In addition, non-academic staff members had to

Sign Up for Unlimited Study Help

Our semester plans gives you unlimited, unrestricted access to our entire library of resources —writing tools, guides, example essays, tutorials, class notes, and more.

Get Started Now